MY ESSAYS

Personal histories and essays on history and everyday life

  • Heart of A Dog by Bulgakov

    On a cold, grey street in 1920s Moscow, a dog lies waiting to die. His name is Sharik.

    There is Filipp Filippovich, a mad bourgeois doctor who believes medical science can yield an elixir of youth, a remedy that has long been the stuff of magic. At his side are Bormenthal, his ambitious but courteous and well-meaning aide, and Zina, his assistant.

    We do not always show one another the cruel and savage side of our nature. All too often, it is the defenceless dogs and cats on the streets who bear the brunt of it. Sharik has had more than his share of that cruelty. He lies on the cold pavement, half his body burned, waiting for death.

    Then a hero comes along. He takes Sharik in and feeds him. And here, for the first time, something human stirs in Sharik. He thinks. He thinks and tries to make sense of what has happened to him. His canine mind may be unequal to the task, but in his dog’s heart he feels a deep respect for Filipp Filippovich, the man who saved him.

    Only later does the reader realise that Filipp stood to gain from taking Sharik in. I think Bulgakov’s critique of the bourgeoisie is particularly subtle here. In his telling, the bourgeois will never, ever lift a finger unless there is something in it for him.

    Eventually, our doctors transplant organs from a dead criminal into Sharik. They mean to make him younger. To their surprise, they make him human. As he changes, Sharik displays traits he never showed as a dog. In becoming human, he grows ‘savage’.

    It falls to Filipp to teach him manners. I could put myself in the doctor’s place. I sometimes think of myself as sympathetic to the left, yet I came away convinced that the doctor was right. Perhaps that has something to do with the way Bulgakov tells the story. Bourgeois though he is, Filipp has devoted himself to science and to humanity. He treats people from other classes rudely, with the assurance of a man who knows he belongs to the upper class. In his eyes, some people really are beneath him. The book comes into sharper focus once you see that.

    At the end of the book, the doctor takes the very creature he forced into being and changes it back. He does it with his own hands and on his own terms.

    To me, that is where the book’s deepest contradiction lies. By turning Sharik back into a dog, the doctor thinks he has put everything back the way it was. But what’s done is done. Eyes have been opened. People know now what can be done. Even the animals know. Without realising it, the doctor has changed something in the world. Just as socialism did.

Essays of My Experiences